Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance Palette Reviews Swatches Bad Review

Anastasia Beverly Hills – Modern Renaissance Palette // Review!

Hey guys!  I’ve been meaning to do this post for a little while.  I know what you’re thinking… there are already about 250,002 reviews of the Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance Palette online.  Why do we need one more?  Well the reason I’m putting in my two pence worth is that I seem to have a different opinion to everyone else!

Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance Palette Reviews Swatches Bad Review

Anastasia Beverly Hills – Modern Renaissance Palette


The Price

I umm’d and ahh’d over getting this palette for such a long time.  It looked beautiful and the deep red and pink colours were right up my street!  The YouTubers were raving about it, and everyone I knew who had got their hands on one seemed to love it.  Once I finally decided to buy it, it was of course out of stock everywhere (this palette was hard work to get hold of!)  When it finally appeared back on Cult Beauty I decided to go for it!

The Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance Palette costs £41 from most reputable sources in the UK (don’t fall for the £20 Ebay fakes!!)  This is a pretty eye watering price, but ABH isn’t made in the UK.  If you’re lucky enough to live in America, it’s a bit cheaper, at around £33.  I wouldn’t usually spend that much on a palette for myself (my husband has bought most of my more expensive makeup as birthday presents).  Saying that, it had SUCH amazing reviews, I decided it’d be worth it.


The Packaging

The first thing I wasn’t keen on was the velvet palette!  The material is a pretty colour, but it feels kind of gross and is the worst idea for a makeup palette!  Obviously makeup can get quite messy, and you can usually give things a wipe off if you get eyeshadow all over them.  With this, the second you get anything on it (even from it being in your makeup bag), the outer palette looks grimy and horrible!  It’s unique, but I’m not a fan personally.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance Palette Reviews Swatches Bad Review

Anastasia Beverly Hills – Modern Renaissance Palette

The brush that comes inside the palette is your usual palette shadow brush.  It’s double ended, with a very loose fluffy brush and a slightly more dense one.  I tried to use it a couple of times, but it just wasn’t good enough.  You couldn’t get any intensity or pack on shadows with it.  This is pretty standard for brushes included in palettes though!  It has a decent mirror, which is useful for on the go.


The Eyeshadows

On first impression, the colours were as gorgeous as I expected!  They have some really unique shadows in there, and some lovely, super intense looking shadows.  Venetian Red (a bright but deep red) and Love Letter (an intense fuchsia) were the ones I was most excited about.  Primavera was a nice lid shimmer.  So of course I got to swatching!

Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance Palette Swatches Pale Skin Reviews Swatches Bad Review

Anastasia Beverly Hills – Modern Renaissance Palette Swatches (Top Row)

The colours came off pretty well when swatched.  They were all pretty intense and true to the colours in the pan.  I definitely thought I’d made a good purchase by this point!  

Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance Palette Swatches Pale Skin Reviews Swatches Bad Review

Anastasia Beverly Hills – Modern Renaissance Palette Swatches (Bottom Row)

The problem came when I tried to actually use them on my eyes.  I found that nearly all the shadows had a TON of fall out (meaning lots of shadow falls onto your face when doing your eyes).  I really struggled to get anything near the pigmentation I got from swatching the eyeshadows.  

So I tried a few different looks, using the various shades.  Each time, I got a really disappointing finish.  I reeeeally wanted Love Letter to work as it was my favourite shade.  I tried it dry, and also on a brush sprayed with setting spray (like Mac Fix Plus).  I had to literally LAYER it to get any decent colour pay-off from it, and even then it was nothing to write home about!  (Does anyone write home about anything anymore?  Haha!)  Primavera, a shimmery gold, was probably the best of the lot.  It was nice for a subtle lid colour and in the inner corners.


Anastasia Beverly Hills – Modern Renaissance Palette : Overall Impression

Overall, after several uses, I was just really disappointed.  I gave it my best shot, but just couldn’t get the palette to work its magic for me 🙁  I even wondered whether I’d received a duff one, since everyone and their dog seem to love their palettes!  It makes me wonder whether it’s my skin tone that’s partly the problem.  I tend to suit cool-toned makeup much better than warm-toned.  This palette is definitely geared towards more warm tones.  So that might explain why the shadows never seemed to look very good on me, but doesn’t explain the pigmentation, application issues and fall out.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance Palette Reviews Swatches Bad Review

Anastasia Beverly Hills – Modern Renaissance Palette

If I haven’t put you off and you still want to get your hands on the Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance Palette, you can currently find it here on Net a Porter for £41.  It does tend to go in and out of stock a lot, so you can also check out Cult Beauty and Beauty Bay.

ABH are cruelty-free, which is fab.  I’m not sure whether this palette is vegan or not (if you know, let us all know in the comments please!)


Never miss a post by clicking below to follow me on Bloglovin!

Follow

Never miss another post from me! Click below to follow me on Bloglovin. If RSS or social media are more your style, check out my sidebar! Follow

10 thoughts on “Anastasia Beverly Hills – Modern Renaissance Palette // Review!

  1. HayleyLoves says:

    thank you for this post! I like it when bloggers give their honest opinion on a product even if it goes against what everyone else is saying 🙂 they do look really pretty in the palette though. Seriously who ever thinks velvet is a good idea for make up packaging need to give their head a shake! haha 🙂

    http://www.hayleyloves.uk

    • Katie Cupcake - Life with ME says:

      Aww you’re welcome – thank you for taking the time to read it! It’s so strange to have a completely different opinion to nearly everyone else.. you start wondering if you got a one-off crap one lol! The same happened with the Barry M Lip Oils – they were terrible! And Tanya Burr Eyeshadow Palettes… and I’m really not that fussy haha! I know, velvet is the worst packaging idea 😀 xx

  2. Donna says:

    The colours look beautiful. It’s such a shame that they were disappointing when it came to using them. I’d be hopeless with products like this with a ton of fallout haha, I’d end up in a right mess!

  3. Sade says:

    You’re 100% right about this palette. I just got my hands on it yesterday and I’m rather disappointed. Fall out is crazy, and all that falls out doesn’t even stick on the lids. I had to resort to using my fingers whixh gave the intensity I was looking but it still didn’t even last. I honestly believe it was great when it first came out. But because the demand was so great they rush this second batch. I waited so long to get this palette and unfortunately it’s a huge disappointment

    • Katie Cupcake - Life with ME says:

      Oh no! I’m so sorry you were disappointed too 🙁 It sucks when you’ve spent so much money on something and had such high expectations! I do wonder about them being different batches, as I’ve seen people use it on YouTube with no issues. Guess we just got unlucky! Have a great Christmas xx

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *